Places of worship

Churches in Jurong West

Keeping church halls, classrooms and offices ready for Sunday, and a phase-by-phase plan to replace around ten ageing systems one at a time, so the cost is spread instead of paid all at once or again and again in repairs.

Illustration, not a drawing of the site

The brief

Congregations in a shared church building in Jurong West needed their halls, classrooms and offices kept cool, leaks dealt with, and an answer to systems that kept breaking down. Replacing every system at once was not affordable; repairing them one fault at a time was costing more each year.

What we found

  • We worked from the building's as-built ACMV drawings to locate every unit, its drainage and the ventilation before taking the work on, and checked that every system could be serviced and vacuumed and its drain lines were clear.
  • The air-conditioning is around ten separate systems of different ages, from small rooms to a 28 kW ducted system in the main hall.
  • Two Mitsubishi Electric VRF systems, about nine years old, had needed power and control boards, fan motors and an expansion valve within months of each other, and one was faulting again. Once a system of this age starts failing like this, part-by-part repair approaches the cost of replacement without fixing the underlying age.
  • Office and meeting-room cassettes had failed drain pumps and float switches, the cause of the leaks.

What we recommended

Replace the systems phase by phase rather than all at once: the failing ones first, the rest in order of condition as they reach the end of their life, so the church spreads its outlay across budgets and stops paying for repairs on systems it is about to replace. Choose one brand now so every phase matches. We compared two side by side: Midea matches every capacity in the building, including the main hall, but needs new control wiring to each condensing unit; Daikin's wiring follows the existing route, but its nearest main hall unit is 5 to 6% smaller. Meanwhile, keep repairing only what is worth repairing.

The work

  • Quarterly servicing per congregation, scheduled around services and events
  • Chemical servicing of 19 ceiling cassettes across a hall, classrooms, offices and a meeting room
  • Weekday call-outs cleared before the weekend services
  • Drain pumps and float switches replaced, water trays cleaned and drain lines flushed
  • Power and control boards, fan motors and an expansion valve replaced on two VRF systems
  • Phased replacement plan for the building's systems, starting with the failing system, with two brand options priced and compared on capacity match and wiring

The result

The halls and rooms stay running through services and events, and the church has a costed, phase-by-phase route to replacing its ageing systems: spending on the worst first, one brand throughout, and no more money spent repairing systems that are due for replacement.