The brief
The main contractor renovating parts of two church sites called us in for untidy air-conditioning wiring. More issues followed: rooms losing fresh air, cassettes faulting, two offices that would not stay cool, and water dripping into a ceiling.
What we found
- Wiring: the control cabling for two VRV systems ran the full height of the building from condensing units on the first floor, loose in the ceiling, with no containment and no spare length. Tidying it in place would have meant pulling a long, fragile run that can fail at commissioning.
- Fresh air: ducts to three fan coil units had pulled off at their joints because nothing carried their weight. Tracing the rest of the system turned up a broken hard-duct joint and a ventilation fan running weak at the end of its life.
- Drainage: drains to ten cassettes had sagged and partly choked with biofilm. Because the lines are linked, the sag had flattened the falls next to it, so water returned to the units and their drain pumps short-cycled, which is what kills pumps.
- Sengkang: two ducted units cooled for minutes and then warmed. Both had failed liquid and gas pipe sensors and a faulty expansion valve coil, the three parts of one control loop. On one, an earlier replacement sensor had been tied nearby rather than fitted in its slot.
- The ceiling leak traced to a corroded cover and an open gap on the roof pipe riser, and to pipe insulation squeezed thin at two supports, where condensation forms.
What we recommended
Fix each at its root, not at the symptom: new riser cabling in conduit from the condensing units up, bundled to the pipework, while the ceiling was open; all ten drains re-run together, since patching one length only moves the sag along; all three control parts replaced together; the riser made watertight first, before anyone looked at the roof slab. Because the drainage fault ran across a whole group of units, we proposed a systematic condition check of all 216 units on both sites, to give the church one asset register and a ranked list of what needs work now, what can be programmed and what can be watched.
The work
- New control cabling for two VRV systems, from the condensing units to the cassettes, in PVC conduit bundled to the refrigerant pipework
- Fresh-air ducting to three fan coil units replaced on new ceiling brackets, the broken duct joint re-sealed, and the weak ventilation fan replaced with new wiring
- Condensate drains re-run to ten cassettes in new insulated pipe, set to a continuous fall and water-tested
- Sensors and expansion valve coils replaced on two ducted units from the ceiling, without opening the refrigerant circuit, so the rest of the system kept running
- Corroded roof riser cover replaced in galvanised steel, the gap closed, and insulation added at the compressed supports
- Systematic condition check of both installations, unit by unit, with faults reported as they are found
The result
Each fault was closed at its cause, in writing and with photographs. The condition check is under way across both sites, and has already flagged a faulty changeover panel on a server room's duty and standby units and an air handling unit fault, before either caused a failure.